The Art of Argument: Learning Logical Fallicies

by Jimmie Lanley on May 23, 2013

ART OF ARGUMENT curriculum review

This post does contain Amazon affiliate links, but I don’t have any special relationship with Classical Academic Press other than being a happy customer.

I’m a sucker for elective courses that are important but don’t fit neatly into a label of history or language arts. The Art of Argument is a perfect example. Logical fallacies? What kind of thing is that to study?

My husband loves philosophy, and we  have heard him talk about straw man arguments, ad hominem attacks, and equivocation. After going through The Art of Argument, now we know exactly what those mean!

I bought The Art of Argument (student book and teacher’s guide) by Classical Academic Press at the Great Homeschool Convention in Memphis in 2012. We used it this last semester of eighth grade as a study in logical argumentation.

About Art of Argument Curriculum

The teacher’s guide has all the answers to the discussion questions, chapter reviews, and cumulative reviews. The front and back inside covers have handy lists of all the different fallacies covered in the course. That chart was invaluable to us as we did the chapter reviews, and I loved that both teacher’s guide and student book had that same chart.

These fallacies have fancy names (often in Latin), and having a concise reference helped us to learn the distinctions between very similar types of arguments.

A huge plus of the book is the ample use of examples of the fallacies. Not only are there text examples that are fully explained, but there are also contrived advertisements, often very humorous or ridiculous, which drive home the points. With the combination of my reading aloud and the visual aids, this curriculum was a good fit for Emma’s learning style. And I have to admit, I really enjoyed learning the technical names of arguments that intuitively seemed wrong to me.

I didn’t make it a formal study with lots of writing. We typically did the exercises aloud instead of writing them down. I wanted the material to be more of a life skill course than an academic one. That may seem ironic since the logical fallacies suit a rigorous classical educator. But on my part, I see the fallacies as practical life skills.

The book is a bit wordy. Sometimes I simplified the explanations to state more concisely what the authors rambled around to say. I guess I prefer a more direct style of communication. In my opinion, the authors sometimes used too much repetition and too many words to get their points across.

The Art of Argument as Life Skills

1. Christian apologetics

Defending the faith will probably be a large part of Emma’s future, so understanding how to argue with precision and logic will be an important ability. (Note that argue does not mean quarrel but to convincingly state a position. You could also use the synonyms discuss or debate.)

2. Understanding marketing, advertising, and political campaigns

With so much propaganda surrounding us online, on television, and in print, it is critical that we recognize how we may be duped or misled by faulty arguments. One of the highlights of this course was hearing Emma identify fallacies from other places — conversations at church, television commercials, at The Creation Museum, and in books.

We did a study of advertising in sixth grade, but The Art of Argument takes those basic ideas to a much deeper level. Eighth grade is a perfect time for such a study as she has the maturity and experience to understand the examples in the book and then identify them in real life.

3. Communication skills

Knowing the right and wrong ways to argue can only help Emma’s overall communication skills. This is one of her strengths already, and The Art of Argument made her an stronger communicator by labeling logical arguments.

 

{ 2 comments }

Preparing to Homeschool High School

by Jimmie Lanley on May 20, 2013

My mindset for homeschooling high school. Jimmie's Collage

This week marks the end of eighth grade, the end of middle school for my only child. That season of life is over, and I have only four more years of home education with Emma — high school.

Although I taught in a public high school many years ago, I do admit that moving into ninth grade has given me some anxiety. My (required by state of TN) umbrella school says I have to have a clear plan before I start the school year with recognized curriculum names. The thought that I can’t homeschool on the fly makes me feel boxed in and nervous.

Deciphering what is required by the state and what is required by colleges is a bit confusing. And then there is the whole issue of a transcript and the record keeping that goes with it. The stakes are just a bit higher now, and there is more accountability from outsiders who may not see eye to eye with my take on what home education should look like for my own daughter.

One of my strategies for dealing with anxiety is to look backwards and see how God led me through the past, knowing he will do the same in the future.  We’ve had crazy years when we got “behind” and had loads of emotional trauma. But Emma is still on track.

  • Her recent standardized test scores reflect that she is at or above grade level.
  • She is articulate, able to handle herself in all kinds of situations, and has great people skills.
  • She is a good writer and has a love for foreign language and art.

In meditating on our situation, I sensed these convictions about homeschooling high school. They may be counter to popular opinion, but that seems to be how God normally leads me — that narrow path.

1. Invest in strengths not weaknesses.

My plan is to invest both time and money into Emma’s strengths and passions — writing, art, and foreign language — instead of paying tutors to help her with the areas in which she may be less enthusiastic about or less proficient in.

For those harder or less liked areas, we will do what is required but no more.

I want her passions to blossom during these four years of high school, and I’m willing to sacrifice other areas to make that happen.

2. Trust God to work out the details.

I refuse to be anxious about curriculum choices and grades. Our path has worked so far. It will not fail us now.

I will be diligent to make good choices and keep Emma accountable to her learning goals. God will fill in any gaps we leave.

Armed with those two messages about homeschooling through the high school years, I sat through two sessions this weekend by two amazing homeschool speakers — Debra Bell and Heidi St. John. You won’t be surprised to hear that the messages they shared were exactly in line with what I was already feeling about our homeschool path.

High School Lessons from Debra Bell

I have read my copy of  The Ultimate Guide to Homeschooling Teens, but I still wanted to hear from the author Debra Bell in person once again. I heard her at Real Refreshment Retreat Atlanta and felt an immediate connection to her. She speaks truth in a very sincere and not preachy way.

This weekend she shared story after story of how God ordained different experiences in her children’s lives that have worked to prepare them precisely for the role they now have in life. Sometimes those experiences were sought after and deliberate, but more often than not, they were accidental or providential, I should say.

Her bottom line was be open to possibilities. Plan but hold the plan loosely because you don’t know the fullness of God’s plan for your child.

High School Lessons from Heidi St. John

Heidi is another person I connected with at Real Refreshment Retreat Atlanta, so when I saw she was talking about high school, I made a beeline for her session.

She emphasized relationship over academics and listening to your children to make high school a special time for them. She was very empowering, encouraging all the moms that we can homeschool high school. It is not as scary as we think it is.

High School Lessons from Lee Binz

I didn’t meet Lee Binz this weekend, but I listened to a webinar by her many months ago. I love her no nonsense approach to high school that left me feeling empowered to conquer this task.

I am going to be using her Total Transcript Solution to keep me on track for Emma’s high school requirements. And I am so excited to share that on June 25 Lee will be giving a free webinar about high school especially for my readers. If you have a child in grades 6th or up, I suggest you come listen to her. She will reassure you that you can homeschool high school.I’ll be sharing more about it in the weeks to come.

{ 17 comments }

An Imperfect Homeschool: Revelations From Behind the Blog

May 9, 2013

Edited to add:  I have to share the irony of my blogging blunder. My post was live and being shared via social media, and I suddenly realized I never added an image. This is one of the cardinal rules of blogging:  always have an image or graphic. And I forgot. Imperfect Homeschool and Imperfect Blogging. [...]

Read the full article →

When Your Homeschooled Child Doesn’t Like to Read

April 30, 2013

(image credit) Today I want to shatter the stereotype of the bookish homeschool kid. Guess what? Not all homeschooled children like to read. Yes, it’s the truth. And my daughter is one of those. My daughter doesn’t like to read. Making it a big heading like that makes me feel better, like I’m confessing a [...]

Read the full article →

Figures of Speech and Poetic Devices Free Printable Mini-posters

April 11, 2013

[To keep getting posts from Jimmie's Collage, please subscribe here. This is the last post that will be issued via Feedburner. If you have already subscribed, thank you!] My Poetic Devices Reference Minibook is wildly popular thanks to Pinterest pins. Unfortunately, the original printable I used to make that minibook has been removed from the Internet. So I [...]

Read the full article →

Homeschool Field Trip to The Creation Museum

April 9, 2013

[To keep getting posts from Jimmie's Collage, please subscribe here. I will be discontinuing the Feedburner feed this week.] On April 3 Emma and I toured the Creation Museum in Kentucky. [Disclosure: We received free tickets to the museum, planetarium, and workshop in exchange for an honest review of our experience.] There were two other iHomeschool [...]

Read the full article →

How to Read Jimmie’s Collage

April 1, 2013

Although my blogging frequency has declined, I have no intentions of giving up blogging. I have decided to let go of blog guilt and blog when I really have something to say, something that makes a difference. If life is too busy for blogging, so be it. Life gets priority over blogging. My goal is [...]

Read the full article →

Extending Special Grace: Lessons Learned from Real Refreshment Retreat

March 29, 2013

Disclosure: My ticket and accommodations to Real Refreshment Retreat were provided by Apologia Ministries in exchange for authentic social media coverage of the event. I was not instructed what to say or how to express my views. I genuinely desired to attend this event, and all of my statements about RRR are my own opinion. [...]

Read the full article →

Online Homeschool Classes with CurrClick

March 21, 2013

Follow my blog with Bloglovin Although I love a routine, things can get bogged down in a rut if we aren’t careful to inject variety. I have just become a fan of a new way of learning — online classes, specifically CurrClick’s live, online, homeschool classes.  I have used online webinars for several years for my [...]

Read the full article →

I Can’t Homeschool Because I’m a Work at Home Mom

March 12, 2013

There are plenty of challenges in homeschooling. But there are very few true obstacles that keep a family from homeschooling. I’m joining up with the bloggers and friends of iHomsechool Network to address the most commonly used reasons people think they can’t homeschool. Of course, we think that most of these, although valid challenges, are [...]

Read the full article →